November 22, 2024 - Track Survey
by William D
This was my wife's and my 3rd time renting Catherine House and we have already secured a rental May 31st - June 7th, 2025! The house was extremely clean...kudos to the cleaning person...and we found the kitchen very well equipped. We ate our lunches and dinners out but had our breakfasts at the house. We were pleased that there was an electric kettle as we're tea drinkers. The pool and outside space was very clean and welcoming. We don't have any suggestions as to how to make the place any better as a rental!
June 25, 2024 - Track Survey
by Marc Daniel
Everything was perfect. It was a great home for a visit to key west and the pool was a godsend during the hot days.
June 17, 2024 - Track Survey
by Lee W
Our place was wonderful! Very clean and comfortable. We we really enjoyed this place during our stay.
April 15, 2024 - Track Survey
by Dylan Shadinger
Overall great experience. Will book again!
April 10, 2024 - Track Survey
by Patrick Diggins
Wonderful cottage for a long weekend visit. Thank you!
February 10, 2024 - Track Survey
by Ben Whitis
Fantastic location just off Duval street. We never rented a car or even a bicycle just walked everywhere.
January 28, 2024 - Track Survey
by Marvin Webster
Catherine House was such a sweet historic home. Very comfortable and the location is very convenient. Very walkable to everything and we also enjoyed renting bikes and riding around in the historic neighborhoods.
January 5, 2024 - Track Survey
by Scott Rogers
Charming cottage with a rich history. Location was perfect and parking was not an issue as we found parking directly in front of the cottage. Parking our golf cart on the property was a very nice plus as well although we were also able to find parking on the street in front of the cottage as well for the cart.
November 19, 2023 - Track Survey
by Ronald Riley
Very easy to deal with. Beautiful property
October 31, 2023 - Track Survey
by Edna Taylor
The house and location were perfect. Could not have asked for a better experience.
Thank you for staying with us and taking the time to review our property. We are delighted to hear that you found both the house and location perfect! We hope to see you again in the future!
October 14, 2023 - Website
by Jim Oechsler
Great location, very clean 2 superior king master bedroom, cute small pool. Everything one needs for stress less vacation. It was better in person than deplicted in your advertisements. We will be back in 2026 for our daughters 25th & our 50th wedding anniversary.Thanks for a great vacation
Thank you for the wonderful review! We are happy to hear that you enjoyed your time at Catherine House. We look forward to having you stay with us again in 2026!
October 12, 2023 - Track Survey
by James Oechsler
Beyond our wildest expectations. This is best property we have ever rented. Thanks
Thank you for staying with us! We are happy to that you enjoyed your stay at Catherine House and we hope to see you again!
October 3, 2023 - Track Survey
by Megan Chapman
We had a great time! The Catherine house was clean and close to everything we needed. The pool was perfect.
September 19, 2023 - Track Survey
by Angela Cockerham
Fantastic location and the house had all the necessities, plus a few extras we did not expect.
Thank you for your Five Star review of Catherine House Key West. We are We are thrilled that you enjoyed the house, all that it offers, and its fantastic location! We look forward to welcoming you back again soon!
September 12, 2023 - Track Survey
by Keith Boleyn
Great floor plan. Nice neighborhood.
Thank you for your Five Star review of Catherine House Key West. We are so glad that you enjoyed the house and its nice neighborhood in Old Town. We look forward to welcoming you back again soon!
August 25, 2023 - Track Survey
by Barry Bowman
518 Catherine provides a perfect Key West experience!!!!! The home is impeccably appointed, beautifully decorated and close to everything.
Thank you for your Five Star review of Catherine House Key West. We are delighted that the home provided you a perfect Key West experience and that you enjoyed its convenient location. We look forward to welcoming you back again soon!
August 7, 2023 - Track Survey
by Jodi Begala
We loved this cottage, great comfortable king size beds are a must and these did not disappoint. The pool was a great addition.
July 23, 2023 - Track Survey
by Deidrea Niece
Thank you for your Five Star review of Catherine House Key West. We hope to welcome you back soon!
April 26, 2023 - Track Survey
by Jill Crabtree
The house was amazing and perfect for two couples. Already looking in to our next visit!
Thank you for your Five Star review of Catherine House Key West. We are thrilled that you enjoyed the house and we look forward to your next visit!
December 23, 2022 - Track Survey
by Bob And Donna Hartley / Jancsy
We had an awesome time. Already planning a return for next year.
Thank you for your Five Star review of Catherine House Key West. We are so glad that you had an awesome time and we look forward to welcoming you back soon!
November 27, 2022 - Track Survey
by Kaitlin Edward
We had a fantastic stay, the house was clean and more than enough space for four of us. Thank you!
Thank you for your Five Star review of Catherine House Key West. We are so happy that you had a fantastic stay and we hope to welcome you back again soon!
November 26, 2022 - Website
Even Better in Person!
by Katie Edwards
My husband and I have been coming to KW for over ten years and usually stay in a hotel, we brought our kids with us and decided to rent a house….. we may never stay in a hotel again! This house has everything you need and then some, it’s much more spacious than the pictures show and we loved the eclectic island-themed decor. The location is minutes away from our favorite side of Duval and we enjoyed walking to the surrounding eateries. We very much enjoyed our stay, thank you!
Thank you for your Five Star review of Catherine House Key West. We are so pleased that you enjoyed the house and its convenient location. We hope to welcome you back again soon!
November 16, 2022 - Track Survey
by Joyce Gagnon
Great house...so nicely decorated...did not seem like a rental..your office was wonderful!!
Thank you for your Five Star review of Catherine House Key West! We are so glad that you enjoyed the house, its decor and our wonderful office staff. We look forward to welcoming you back again soon!
Great Home in Key West
by shane K.
We had a wonderful time in the keys, thanks to this home. This home was perfect for a family of three and offered plenty of room and was within walking distance to everything Duval street had to offer. Manager's ResponseThank you for your review of Catherine House and your recommendation. We are so glad the home was perfect for your family and that you enjoyed its convenient location. We hope to welcome you back again soon!
Thank you for your review of Catherine House and your recommendation. We are so glad the home was perfect for your family and that you enjoyed its convenient location. We hope to welcome you back again soon!
So cute and well appointed!
by Martha D.
This is a great place to stay in Key West!Manager's ResponseThank you for your Five Star review of Catherine House. We are so glad that you enjoyed your stay and we look forward to welcoming you back soon!
Thank you for your Five Star review of Catherine House. We are so glad that you enjoyed your stay and we look forward to welcoming you back soon!
Very Nice Home
by Recent Guest
The location was excellent and the home was large enough for four adults with the exception of the living room area, which had a couple of chairs and small couch so it was tight in the evenings for four people.Manager's ResponseThank you for your Five Star review of Catherine House. We hope to welcome you back again soon!
Thank you for your Five Star review of Catherine House. We hope to welcome you back again soon!
Getaway with the girls
by Recent Guest
My sister and I took our mother to the keys for the first time. She had a wonderful time! Loved the house so much that we ordered take out most nights!The only suggestion I have would be to have bar soap available. We had every other kind of soap, just no soap for the shower. Manager's ResponseThank you for your Five Star Review of Catherine House! We are so glad that you had a wonderful time. We appreciate your feedback and suggestions and hope to welcome you back soon!
Thank you for your Five Star Review of Catherine House! We are so glad that you had a wonderful time. We appreciate your feedback and suggestions and hope to welcome you back soon!
Excellent Experience
by Recent Guest
Very comfortable house and ideal location. Close to Duvall Street.Manager's ResponseThank you for your Five Star review of Catherine House! We are so happy you enjoyed the house and its ideal location close to Duval Street. We look forward to welcoming you back soon!
Thank you for your Five Star review of Catherine House! We are so happy you enjoyed the house and its ideal location close to Duval Street. We look forward to welcoming you back soon!
Great rental!
by Lanna N.
Catherine House was very clean and comfortable! It’s a great location, easy walk to Duval Street. Loved everything, would highly recommend!!Manager's ResponseThank you for your Five Star Review of Catherine House. We are so glad you enjoyed the house and its great location. We greatly appreciate your recommendation and look forward to welcoming you back soon!
Thank you for your Five Star Review of Catherine House. We are so glad you enjoyed the house and its great location. We greatly appreciate your recommendation and look forward to welcoming you back soon!
Best of Key West
by Amanda S.
We had a phenomenal time at 518 Catherine- such a charming, well appointed and wonderfully located cottage. We loved every moment and hope to return some day.Manager's ResponseThank you for your Five Star Review of Catherine House. We are so glad you enjoyed the house and its wonderful location. We greatly appreciate your recommendation and hope you will return soon!
Thank you for your Five Star Review of Catherine House. We are so glad you enjoyed the house and its wonderful location. We greatly appreciate your recommendation and hope you will return soon!
February 1, 2022 - Website
Beautiful house
by Billy T.
This was our first real vacation since Covid started. Key West is our favorite spot to be. Catherine house was amazing. it was perfect for our little get away. we enjoyed sitting by the pool, the house was very clean and decorated so cute and tropical. the location was perfect. Quiet but close to all the action. The rental agency was very accommodating to our needs. we cannot wait to rent Catherine house again on our next trip down. We highly recommend this rental for the perfect vacation in paradise. 🙂
January 1, 2022 - Website
Good
by Fred D.
everyything was great clean good location
January 1, 2022 - Website
Nice stay at quaint vacation spot!
by Recent Guest
Catherine House is conveniently located in Old Town and nicely kept by the owners. Enjoyed being supplied with some necessities while there. Very comfortable and peaceful.
December 1, 2021 - Website
Catherine House
by Jennifer C.
We had a great stay at Catherine House. My husband and myself, along with our 22 and 17 year olds really enjoyed the house. The house is so charming and had everything we needed.
November 1, 2021 - Website
Perfect Vacation Cottage
by Kim C.
The Catherine House was the perfect cottage for my husband and I. It was in a great location, close to the action and within walking distance to everywhere. The house was incredibly clean when we arrived and had everything we needed. Although the weather was perfect, we didn't get a chance to use the pool. The bed was extremely comfortable and the cottage is nicely decorated. We would definitely recommend this house and will be back to stay again!
November 1, 2021 - Website
Catherine House
by Jo C.
Beautiful rental that met all our needs. Easy walking to places we visited. Neighborhood felt safe
October 1, 2021 - Website
Absolutely perfect!
by Tara C.
Catherine House was absolutely perfect! The decor is adorable. It was spotlessly clean. We had everything we needed, including a very well stocked kitchen. A private back yard with a pool. And the location is ideal (half block off the quieter end of Duval). Honestly, we couldn’t be happier and hope to rent Catherine House again when we come back to Key West.
September 1, 2021 - Website
Nice house in excellent location.
by Kevin M.
Really great experience. The rental was the perfect size and was super-close to everything yet still quiet at night.Only 1/2 block from great cafes and restaurants and 1 block from bicycle rental companies.
Darling little cottage near Duvall
by Katie D.
The cottage is very bright and quintessentially Key West. The property was very clean and had a great layout for our family. A bike rack behind the fence was a great touch for us. The pool was small (as pictured), but perfect for a couple and a toddler. We really enjoyed the privacy the pool area afforded. The property management company was very helpful. Check-in was simple and they offered to watch our bags between our check-out time and departure. I would highly recommend this property for a getaway for a small family or a few friends. We really enjoyed touring the Butterfly and Nature Conservatory, breakfast at Frenchie's Cafe and Kaya Island Eats for their signature tuna poke (WOW) and tiki-style cocktails.
Catherine House is a WINNER!
by Jill A.
The experience both with Key West Rentals and specifically at the Catherine House was wonderful. The house was exactly as expected and had everything we needed. It was quiet, super clean and close to everything. No need to rent a car, scooter or bike - we walked the entire island and what a treat to come back to a cool, clean bright and sunny house and take a dip in the pool. We were visited daily at the pool by a family of iguana's walking along the fenceline. If returning to Key West, I would definitely only stay at Catherine House!
A Perfect Cottage Style House
by Candis M.
This house was perfect for our group of four. Bedrooms situated on either side of living & kitchen space, the patio was very nice & private. We loved sitting on the front porch too. The rental office was accommodating to our schedule and the information supplied was very helpful. Great experience. This house in in a great location, close enough to walk to nearby restaurants & shopping. We rented a golf cart to get around the entire island which was so fun. Sunsets on the water were amazing! We booked a sunset cruise with Argo Navis...classy experience, and a 1/2 day boat experience with Easy Day. Went snorkeling & island hopping. You won’t be, or shouldn’t be, disappointed with this property.
The Perfect Vacation Hone
by Amanda M.
This was my second time returning to the Catherine House and it was just as beautiful and perfect as I remember. Beautiful decor, stocked kitchen, amazing patio. Will absolutely be returning!
KW ‘21
by Carolyn B.
This is the third time we’ve stayed at 518. The house is the perfect size for my sister and I. Well maintained. One of the few houses that accept pets. My dog Stitch loves the pool. Very clean Quiet street Good restaurants within walking distance
Awesome Stay at Catherine House
by Recent Guest
Rent Key West service was great from start to finish. They answered all questions promptly and was helpful picking a place to stay in Key West. The Catherine House was amazing. One of the best places we have stayed considering location, cleanliness and amenities. Everything about the Catherine House was amazing. I would stay here again and recommend anyone with 4 people in their party stay here.
A great vacation
by Suzanne K.
The house is really clean and cute. All the decor is really nice. The a/c in the front room is pretty old and prob needs to be replaced. But other than that, has a well appointed kitchen, etc.
KeyWest vacation
by Recent Guest
The house was fantastic, loved having the pool, location was perfect, easy check in and out process.
KeyWest vacation
by Laura P.
The house was fantastic, loved having the pool, location was perfect, easy check in and out process.
Catherine house
by Suzanne R.
We really enjoyed our stay in this well appointed rental home. It is conveniently located on the quieter end of town, but within easy walking distance to everything! The house itself is very clean, updated, and comfortable. Excellent choice!
February 1, 2021 - Website
Best Kept Secret
by Recent Guest
We had a wonderful experience staying at Catherine House! Beautiful interior with original art, close to restaurants, fully equipped kitchen, laundry, plenty of towels, etc. Jann from the management company was very helpful!
January 1, 2021 - Website
Perfect first time trip to Key West
by Recent Guest
We had a great stay. The property is in a great location. Great private deck.
December 1, 2020 - Website
Great property, great location
by Eric L.
This is a great property in a great location 2 blocks from Duval. Lots of really good places to eat within walking distance. Also within walking distance to a liquor store and grocery. This 2 bedroom is very private and is fully stocked. We cooked a large dinner one night and found everything we needed. We’ll definitely stay here again.
February 1, 2020 - Website
Excellent except for mattress and pillows (too firm)
by Amy G.
Quiet area but super close to Duval, easy walk to lots of shops and restaurants. Perfect balance. Great yard with patches of sun and shade all day, beautiful clean little heated dipping pool, comfortable furniture inside and out. Impeccably maintained house and yard. Lovely bed linens, beautiful high end bathrooms, and nice kitchen. Great tech (3 tv’s, fast WiFi, Bluetooth radio). My only complaint is that the mattress was too firm and the pillows were firm foam. I’d like feather pillows and either a softer mattress or the option to have a foam mattress topper put on for my stay. Manager's ResponseThank you for sharing feedback from your stay with us. We appreciate your kind words! Bed comfort is very subjective, as some like a soft bed and others a firm bed. Had we known during your stay that the pillows and bed were too firm for you, we would have brought you different pillows from our office supply. Thank you for staying with us and we hope to see you again!
Thank you for sharing feedback from your stay with us. We appreciate your kind words! Bed comfort is very subjective, as some like a soft bed and others a firm bed. Had we known during your stay that the pillows and bed were too firm for you, we would have brought you different pillows from our office supply. Thank you for staying with us and we hope to see you again!
January 1, 2020 - Website
A Real Charmer
by Dave S.
We thoroughly enjoyed our stay in 518 Catherine. The Cottage is very nicely decorated and quite functional for two couples. Location was great. Just 1.2 block off Duval St. And still very quiet. The facility was very clean upon arrival. We loved the orchids on the patio and the dip pool worked great.
January 1, 2020 - Website
Catherine House
by James C.
Great
January 1, 2020 - Website
Catherine House
by Troy C.
Incredible, third stay at this property and owners clearly re-invest in this home each year. Key West is a unique and beautiful destination and you deserve a home that fits that expectation. Catherine House is just that and the rental office is awesome as they will turn up the heat on the pool, give you great advice on things to do that 'locals do' vs. just vacationers wish list. I will always make the Catherine House a top priority when selecting a perfect "Key West experience" home! Troy Manager's ResponseWe are so happy to hear that you enjoyed Catherine House and appreciate you staying with us! Thank you for the amazing review. Our goal is to go above and beyond to ensure our guests have a memorable and enjoyable experience. The owners appreciate feedback and want to provide a well maintained property. We look forward to having you stay again with us!
We are so happy to hear that you enjoyed Catherine House and appreciate you staying with us! Thank you for the amazing review. Our goal is to go above and beyond to ensure our guests have a memorable and enjoyable experience. The owners appreciate feedback and want to provide a well maintained property. We look forward to having you stay again with us!
November 1, 2019 - Website
Outstanding is understating this bungalow
by Clinton H.
My wife and I would absolutely rent this bungalow again. It was perfect in everyway. We’d even go as far as saying the rental made the entire vacation. The décor is outstanding—it is both comfortable while adding to the unique atmosphere of Key West. The location is perfect--it is just a couple homes off Duval, so it is simultaneously quiet and convenient. Every light switch is on a dimmer, allowing for night time navigation without walking into something. Virtually everything is labeled so you know what it does/how it works. The kitchen is well equipped, and the towels/sheets/blankets are beyond ample. Both the backyard and front porch were very relaxing—we had an occasional rooster swing by to say good morning while we drank our coffee. We even loved all the artwork. The unit was also spotless clean. The entire experience is undoubtedly worthy of five stars (if not more)!Manager's ResponseThank you for the amazing review! We are thrilled your time with us was so great! Our goal is to ensure our guests have a memorable and enjoyable experience. We hope to have you stay with us again!
Thank you for the amazing review! We are thrilled your time with us was so great! Our goal is to ensure our guests have a memorable and enjoyable experience. We hope to have you stay with us again!
October 1, 2019 - Website
2 Couple Retreat
by Jennifer J.
This cute two bedroom cottage is about 60 yards from Duval street. More towards the quiet end and that was enjoyable. Great little bar on the corner called LaTeDa if you want a night cap. Bring beverages and food for the cute kitchen or sit out on the deck or in the tiny pool to cool off and relax. If you want to venture down the street towards the busier part of Duval, it is just about an 8-13 minute walk to get there. Fun, close to everything, clean, cute, quaint, air conditioned and a fun outside shower. House comes with two king beds and both couples have their own full bathroom. We LOVED it and would highly recommend it to anyone wanting to spend some time in the Keys with another good travel couple. Oh yes, the key pad on the door was nice - we didn't have to carry around a key all the time.
Great Little cottage
by Lisa B.
This is the sweetest little cottage. We usually have 8 of us that travel to the Keys each year. This year only 4 of us could go. This cottage was perfect. Close to everything even our favorite Fishing Charter Double Down. We had an amazing time and always felt safe.
Love This Home
by Recent Guest
Whenever we visit Key West we stay at Catherine House. It’s in a great location and love the pool. Just a little disappointed in a couple areas. We stayed for 10 days and the pool was never cleaned/maintenanced, otherwise I loved my stay. Manager's ResponseThank you very much for your review of your recent stay with us. Your feedback is extremely valuable to us. We are concerned that the pool was not cleaned at all during your stay because we pay an outside pool company weekly to clean and test the water. The pool maintenance day is posted on an info sheet in the house. Had we known they did not show up, we would have contacted them immediately. Our main priority is to be able to offer a clean, comfortable, well maintained property, and have our guests enjoy their stay with us.
Thank you very much for your review of your recent stay with us. Your feedback is extremely valuable to us. We are concerned that the pool was not cleaned at all during your stay because we pay an outside pool company weekly to clean and test the water. The pool maintenance day is posted on an info sheet in the house. Had we known they did not show up, we would have contacted them immediately. Our main priority is to be able to offer a clean, comfortable, well maintained property, and have our guests enjoy their stay with us.
Key West at it's Best!
by Larry H.
This place was perfect...wish we were still there! You can't go wrong renting this place. It was awesome!
Awesome house in a great location
by Recent Guest
The house was great as was all correspondence with the property managers. Great location! Loved the pool & outdoor shower! We would definitely stay in the Catharine house again.
Awesome house in a great location
by John B.
The house was great as was all correspondence with the property managers. Great location! Loved the pool & outdoor shower! We would definitely stay in the Catharine house again.
Catherine ohuse
by RUSSELL M.
quaint home in the heart of Old Town Key West...felt like we were right at home....recommend it highly and we will return in the future.Manager's ResponseThank you for the great review! Our goal is to ensure our guests have a memorable and enjoyable experience with us. We look forward to seeing you again in the future.
Thank you for the great review! Our goal is to ensure our guests have a memorable and enjoyable experience with us. We look forward to seeing you again in the future.
Great Place to stay
by Ellen K.
The house was in a perfect location. Close to Duval Street but was still quiet. It was well equipped with everything. Loved sitting on the porch and sitting in the pool. We were with another couple and the lay out of the house was fantastic.Would definitely stay again when in town.
February 1, 2019 - Website
815 Catherine Review
by Recent Guest
Love the house and location !
February 1, 2019 - Website
815 Catherine Review
by Robert K.
Love the house and location !
January 1, 2019 - Website
Nice vacation cottage
by George P.
This was the fifth time we have stayed here. Catherine House is in a good location. It is well equipped for two couples. It has two large bedrooms, each with their own bathrooms.the pool is small but great for cooling off or a nightly dip.
November 1, 2018 - Website
Excellent house and location
by Richard B.
Excellent
October 1, 2018 - Website
2018 Key West Trip
by Joan M.
KW Rentals was great to deal with and the property was awesome!
Excellent experience!
by Recent Guest
Catherine House turned out to be everything we had hoped for! Each room is exactly as it looks in the pictures, no surprises. It's evident the owners have thought of everything you could possibly need and have it available. During our stay temperatures were in the mid 90s with high humidity, but the house was always cool and very comfortable. We loved having our coffee on the front porch in the morning, watching and listening to the roosters across the street. This location is perfect, everything is within an easy bike ride. And working with the rental company was painless, all their associates were beyond friendly and went above and beyond to accommodate us. We can't wait for our next trip and to stay at Catherine House again!
Great Location
by Christopher F.
Great location on quiet end of Duvall. Beds were great. Kitchen had thing you would find at home. Front porch with the haint colored ceiling is perfect for hanging out before heading out. Stayed a week. Rented bikes from Fury two blocks from house across Duvall. Experienced the best things the island had to offer. Garbos, el Siboney, Bien, and Sinz are must eat lunch spots close to the house. Santiago's for dinner. Hit up Mary Ellen's for the Irish coffee with Jameson floater early every day. And eat conch as much as possible. You're going to miss it when you're gone.
Catherine’s Place
by Recent Guest
Loved the house. Wonderful layout for us and a guest. Perfect location. Our guest had the front my bedroom and felt that the air conditioner was a little loud. Took a few days to get use to it. We would definitely stay there again.Manager's ResponseThank you for the review. We are happy you enjoyed the house and location! One of our maintenance staff will take a look at the AC in the front bedroom to see why it is running loud. We would have been happy to do that during your stay if we had known. Thank you again, and hope to see you in the future!
Thank you for the review. We are happy you enjoyed the house and location! One of our maintenance staff will take a look at the AC in the front bedroom to see why it is running loud. We would have been happy to do that during your stay if we had known. Thank you again, and hope to see you in the future!
Great house and Spectacular location
by Michael C.
Place was every bit as nice as advertised; plunge pool was indeed small but felt good after a day on Duval Street. Loved the flora and fauna with even a visit from Mr. Iguana on top of the privacy fence (think he was scamming the next door mango trees). House is right off Duval but on the quieter end of Duval away from Cruise ship crowds. Plenty of great restaurants and bars very close. Recommend place highly!
Catherine house
by Robert H.
What a great property with all the amenities one would want. Great location, close to everything on the south end with easy access to the seaport by short walk or bike ride.
Catherine house
by Gale & Bob H.
What a great property with all the amenities one would want. Great location, close to everything on the south end with easy access to the seaport by short walk or bike ride.
Catherine house
by Recent Guest
What a great property with all the amenities one would want. Great location, close to everything on the south end with easy access to the seaport by short walk or bike ride.
Catherine House
by Allen F.
The house was just as described. It was clean and comfortable. Just 1/2 block off of Duvall street. I would definitely stay here again.Manager's ResponseThank you for your 5 star review! We look forward to you staying with us again!
Thank you for your 5 star review! We look forward to you staying with us again!
Loved this House
by Harriet T.
This is a very cute house, great location, perfectly laid out with two bedrooms at opposite ends of house. Perfect for two couples. Wonderful responsive owner and management. Very clean and well stocked. Would recommend and would return again if visiting Key West in the future. Loved it.
February 1, 2018 - Website
Relaxing Week in Key West
by Recent Guest
Beautiful Catherine House! We had an amazing week in Key West and the house was everything pictured and more. Lovely art work and so many details that set this rental apart from the rest. The rental management was very helpful and called after the first day to make sure we were okay and if we had any questions. Their office was a quick walk from the house. The Catherine House is close to the Duval Loop Bus that we used several times. We used the washer and dryer on the property and cooked three dinners during our stay. The Catherine House is well maintained and spotless. The beds were very comfortable and the bathrooms were like a spa. So yes, we would definitely stay again on vacation!
January 1, 2018 - Website
A cottage oasis
by Sandy S.
The Catherine house is so charming, warm well decorated , clean. This house feels like home
November 1, 2017 - Website
A little piece of paradise
by Alison S.
We and another couple had the pleasure of staying at The Catherine House in November while there for my daughters wedding and this property exceeded our expectations. As one in our party is an interior designer, that is no easy feat. From the location to the dcor, we couldnt have found a better place. This house was immaculately clean and so well appointed with just about anything you could possibly need in the kitchen that we kept joking about it. Of course, there is an ice crusher, who doesnt have one of those? Two bedrooms on opposite ends of the house provide privacy and somehow make the house feel much larger than it is. The main living area is open and airy and provided plenty of room for a wedding party to have their hair and makeup done all while enjoying a brunch spread. In the 6 days that we were there, most of our days and nights were spent out and about but we always looked forward to going home and wrapping up the evening on the front porch or back patio.From the bedding to the towels, the color scheme, the artwork, the fabulous collection of books on Key Westthe owners thought of it all. As our week came to an end, we were sad to leave and all agreed it was the best rental property wed ever stayed in.The staff of Rent Key West Vacations were fabulous to deal with. They happily allowed me to have wedding dcor shipped to their offices without hesitation and when one box got delayed, scheduled to arrive after I left, they took care to ensure it was returned to the shipper.To the owners and the staff of Rent Key West, we thank you for your hospitality and for providing us with our own little slice of the island, if even for a brief time.
Our anniversary and 60th birthday
by Clara E.
We had a very pleasant stay. Loved the home it was clean and spacious. Made us feel at home and located in a great spot. I will be booking again soon. The only wish I have is the pool being bigger. Love my stayManager's ResponseThank you for your wonderful review! We are very happy to hear that you had a nice time and loved the house. The pool at Catherine House is small, but that is common here in Key West. We look forward to you staying with us again!
Thank you for your wonderful review! We are very happy to hear that you had a nice time and loved the house. The pool at Catherine House is small, but that is common here in Key West. We look forward to you staying with us again!
Our anniversary and 60th birthday
by Recent Guest
We had a very pleasant stay. Loved the home it was clean and spacious. Made us feel at home and located in a great spot. I will be booking again soon. The only wish I have is the pool being bigger. Love my stayManager's ResponseThank you for your wonderful review! We are very happy to hear that you had a nice time and loved the house. The pool at Catherine House is small, but that is common here in Key West. We look forward to you staying with us again!
Thank you for your wonderful review! We are very happy to hear that you had a nice time and loved the house. The pool at Catherine House is small, but that is common here in Key West. We look forward to you staying with us again!
Better than expected!
by Recent Guest
My girlfriend and I were in charge of planning a vacation for our husbands and ourselves. Needless to say, we were a bit nervous as we wanted it to be perfect and to our husbands' approval. Boy did we nail it! Everything from location to cleanliness to accommodation! It was exactly what we were looking for!
Another Great Stay in Key West
by Thomas D.
We have stayed here multiple times and enjoy the house due to its location and size ... perfect for 2 or 4 people. It has a small dipping pool with a nice deck surround. The condition of the property is great. Rent Key West is great to work with in finding a great property to meet your needs.
Fabulous Catherine House
by Stefanie C.
The property was perfect for 2 couples!
Classic southern charming home steps away from Duval Street
by Recent Guest
This rental is clean, beautifully maintained and equipped. It is located in a great location, steps away from Duval Street but in a quieter and I think nicer end of Duval. This rental is perfect for 2 couples offering two equally nice masters and baths. The decor is very cute and tasteful. The home has a small but nicely landscaped side patio area, and also front porch perfect for coffee or cocktails. The on site laundry is convenient. The home includes all of the necessities. With the exception of purchasing some food and drinks upon arriving, everything else we needed was found in the home. Rent Key West was great to deal with from start to finish and their office is conveniently located near the rental. Highly recommend this property for 2-4 adults.
February 1, 2017 - Website
Catherine House -- An unexpected treat
by Walter K.
Another couple our age that we often travel with (Alaska, Hawaii, etc.) invited us to join them for a few days to celebrate the wife's 70th birthday in Key West. Since a hotel room in our price range would cost up to $400 per night per couple plus taxes, we decided we could get better quality splitting the cost of a two-bedroom home. We picked Catherine House based on price (under $600 total per night split 50-50), availability (3 nights mid-week), and location (very close to Hemingway House). All we could say on arrival was, "Wow!!!" The outside was routine, but it felt like we had rented space in a gallery with impeccably integrated taste in color schemes, artwork, and furnishings. We never asked, but think some of the signed original artwork might have been custom pieces done by the owner. We visited quite a few galleries during our three days in Key West, and none impressed us as much as this rental. Bottom line: I cant imagine scheduling another trip to Key West without making sure we pick dates when we can stay here again.
January 1, 2017 - Website
A Lovely Place to Stay
by Robert M.
This is our 4th year at Catherine House. It is a great location - near the quiet end of Duval street, the cottage is always in excellent condition, the management company does a wonderful job and I could go on and on. 2 br and 2 ba, though when we stay there it is only my wife and myself. We do not rent a car when staying at Catherine House - everything is within walking distance.
November 1, 2016 - Website
The best place to stay
by Robert C.
We really enjoyed our rental at Catherine house! Everything went easier than I could have expected. We were trading by small aircraft and as such did not have a definite arrival time. We also shipped our luggage ahead to the rental office. When we arrived at the rental office it took just a few minutes to complete the checkin process and then when we asked for our luggage we found it had already been delivered to our house! What service! Once we arrived at the house we found it was perfect for 2 couples for the week. We cooked a few meals there and had everything we needed. It was very clean and really just a great location.
September 1, 2016 - Website
Fun in Paradise
by Recent Guest
The Catherine Street House is my favorite place to stay in Key West. Ideal location to Duval Street and all other KW attractions makes my stay easy and enjoyable. The house is always clean and perfect in every way. Key West Rentals are excellent to work with and care about myweel being while visiting. I will be back.
Simple And Outstanding
by Richard Z.
The quality of this property is outstanding.I could write a lengthy review but, here is what you need to know.Clean, well stocked, excellent location, privacy, quiet street located near everything.Will stay here again without question.Checking in and out was simple. Manager's ResponseThank you for your wonderful review! We truly appreciate your business. We are very happy to hear that you found Catherine House outstanding! We look forward to you staying with us again.
Thank you for your wonderful review! We truly appreciate your business. We are very happy to hear that you found Catherine House outstanding! We look forward to you staying with us again.
Love the Catherine House
by Jane W.
We have stayed at the Catherine House several times and will continue to rent this property. The location is wonderful and we always have a great time there
518 Catherine St
by Steve C.
Very satisfied. Hope to be back in 2017.
Enjoyed our stay
by Thomas D.
We have rented several homes in KW and this was exactly what we wanted. It is close to Duval and within easy walking distance to all of the main attractions and restaurants. It was very clean and the perfect size for just the two of us. The pool is a small dipping pool but worked well to cool off during the day and after dinner in the evenings. We had a great stay.
Nothing but Awesomeness!!!
by John M.
The week went by so fast. Key West is just plain fun! We will be back many times and plan to stay at Catherine House for many reasons. It's cute, comfy, and convenient to everything.We did rent bikes which made KW very enjoyable and small. Never ate at the same restaurant twice, they were all fantastic!
Enjoyed our Time at Catherine HOuse
by Recent Guest
The location was perfect and provided privacy and quietness, but still close enough to the excitement of Duval Street. House was clean, adequately equipped and comfortable. Amenities (linens, appliances, etc.) were high-quality and clean. Would recommend the microwave be placed on the counter and not on top of the fridge as it is dangerous to remove hot fluids from it. We had a repair issue with the dishwasher which was fixed, but the rental agency (Page) left us wasting an entire afternoon for the repair people. It was a miscommunication but tainted our opinion of the rental agency to a certain degree. Still, if we returned to Key West we would possibly consider renting there again. Thank you.
Enjoyed our Time at Catherine HOuse
by Maxine S.
The location was perfect and provided privacy and quietness, but still close enough to the excitement of Duval Street. House was clean, adequately equipped and comfortable. Amenities (linens, appliances, etc.) were high-quality and clean. Would recommend the microwave be placed on the counter and not on top of the fridge as it is dangerous to remove hot fluids from it. We had a repair issue with the dishwasher which was fixed, but the rental agency (Page) left us wasting an entire afternoon for the repair people. It was a miscommunication but tainted our opinion of the rental agency to a certain degree. Still, if we returned to Key West we would possibly consider renting there again. Thank you.
50th birthday
by Recent Guest
Every thing was perfect. Clean quite great location. I would highly recommend this for anyone. We will be back.
February 1, 2016 - Website
Our stay at the Catherine House
by Recent Guest
The house was beyond our expectations. It was beautifully decorated, nice size and met all of our needs. However, we were hugely disappointed with the nearby jackhammers that were constant from 8:00 am until 5:00. I had just paid for the pool to be heated with plans to read by the pool most of the week. That did not happen due to the jackhammering. I do wish I had known in advance about the construction nearby. There is a new hotel being built nearby. Those who plan on sightseeing all day may not mind, but for us it definitely was a disappointment. And I would not have paid for the pool to be heated! Otherwise, the owners of this house clearly take great pride and care of this home.
October 1, 2015 - Website
518 Catherine House
by Recent Guest
Stayed at Catherine House for Fantasy Fest 2015. We are four adults in our sixties and the house was marvelous. Separate a/c in bedrooms and living area accommodated 2 couples very well. We had a slight issue with the pool heat which was addressed and rectified promptly by maintenance. Great location, easy walk to lower Duval St. Quiet 1 way street. Would recommend to family and friends.
Treasure chest of a home!
by Torsten R.
We spent almost a week in the Catherine House and of a total 3 week vacation in Florida, this part was by far the best of the whole trip. So lovely decorated and so charming and comfortable. I wholeheartedly recommend this property to anyone with up to 4 people. Also, dealing with Rental KW was smooth and a pleasure!
Great Property Rental
by Recent Guest
Absolutely loved this property. It had everything that we needed. Location was perfect. I hope to come back and stay here again.
Great location and beautiful house!!!
by Courtney B.
Rent Key West provided us with everything we could possibly ask for! The Catherine House was in a perfect location for a quieter experience, but still so close the everything! We had the vacation of a lifetime and hated to leave, but we will be back!
Wonderful stay at the Catherine House !!
by Recent Guest
This was our first visit to Key West and it definitely will not be our last. This house is perfect for a family or anyone who only needs 2 bedrooms. Everything you could possibly want or need was in the house. Washer, dryer, dishwasher, blow dryers, beach towels, sunscreen, hand soaps, pots, pans, bowls, utensils..etc. The only thing missing was a METAL spatula for the gas grill. The house clean and bright. The pool is small, but if you are only looking to get wet or take a quick dip, it's perfect. It's on a quiet street that is on the quieter end of Duval. Easy walking distance to the Butterfly Conservatory, the Southernmost Point, the Lighthouse, Hemingway House, the Bakery, and various bars and restaurants. Great house, great location!!
Fun in the sun at Catherine House
by Jane W.
This is the second time we have stayed at Catherine House and we loved it just as much as we did the first time. It was recently remodeled and it is wonderful. We will definitely stay here again!
Loved my stay at Catherine House
by Cindy E.
We had a wonderful and fun vacation at Catherine house in the Keys. Great location, quiet and relaxing but close to all activities and action. House was clean and tastefully decorated in Key West decor. Perfect for two or four people. Would highly recommend and hope to visit again soon!
February 1, 2015 - Website
Catherine House
by Robert M.
This is our second visit to Catherine House. It is perfect for us.The place is in excellent condition and is very clean. Air conditioning works well; so does the heat in the pool.Less than one block of a quiet section of Duval St so there are a lot of art galleries and shops to visit.We walk to all the restaurants and don't have a car in Key West.We have never had a security issue.Management company is always cooperative and knowledgeable.We are staying here again next winter. That is the ultimate vote of confidence.
January 1, 2015 - Website
Excellent choice for Key West stay.
by George P.
Very nice cottage.Great location. Very well equipped. Clean and well maintained. Rental agency is great to deal with and promptly responds to any requests or problems.
December 1, 2014 - Website
Great house. Great property management.
by Daryl M.
This is a great house, great layout, and great location. We had an A/C issue for one bedroom. The property manager responded immediately and had a repairman out quickly. The issue was not immediately resolved, but a supplemental unit was installed that helped and an adjustment was made for the issue. Great customer service.
October 1, 2014 - Website
Catherine House....Perfect
by Sandra L.
This was the perfect place to stay in Key West for 2 couples. With 2 bedrooms with adjoining baths there was plenty of privacy. The deck and pool area was the perfect place to gather for morning coffee or a glass of wine in the evening. The house was very clean and fully equipped down to beach towels and lotion. There were plenty of restaurants and tourist attractions within walking distance. The folks at Key West Rentals were so easy to work with. Catherine House will be our first choice the next time we go to Key West.
September 1, 2014 - Website
Wonderful vacation
by Nancie T.
it was wonderful. we had a great time.
Loved every minute
by Recent Guest
The Catherine House was a perfect getaway for myself and my two sisters. It was clean, quiet, well-equipped and just a short walk from Duval Street. I would go back again in a heartbeat.
Great place
by Carrie J.
Great place to stay. Parking was the only negative but would stay again!
Great stay
by Recent Guest
The Catherine house was perfect the pictures didn't do it justice. It was also in a great location. I would definately stay here again if I'm lucky enough to stay in Key West again
Awesome first impression!! At Catherine house:)
by Melissa R.
It was our first time visiting Key West and we decided to rents house with friends from Rent Key West. We chose the Catherine House, it was the best choice EVERRRRRRRRR! We really enjoyed our stay, we had everything we needed in the house all we had to bring was food and clothes. We will definitely be coming back. Thank you Rent Key West!
Catherine House
by Rick E.
The house is fantastic, very private setting around the pool and great location to attractions.
From Canada
by Recent Guest
Loved loved loved the Catherine House. It felt like home.
Great little place!
by Cindy S.
I never give anything a perfect score, but this place gets all 4 stars. It was a very good location for the 4 of us. We parked 2 cars out front most of the time, and there was other parking down the street at other times. We really enjoyed our week.
Location. Location. Location!!
by Barb R.
Perfect place to stay in KW. Within walking distance of everything. Very quiet street. Very clean and well equipped. Will definitely stay there next trip.
Catherine House during March Madness
by Mark H.
This was our second stay at The Catherine House. Just like our first visit, this property allows respite from the craziness of Duval yet it is less than a block away. Very nice upgrades were made to the kitchen and master bath as well. We will be back!
Perfect Wedding/Honeymoon Stay
by Derek R.
We rented this property since we were getting married in Key West and wanted to bring our dogs. It turned out perfect since it was located just off Duval St. but on the quieter end close to the Southernmost Beach. Everything you need is within walking distance except a big grocery store however we ended up enjoying the great restaurants nearby which are all within walking distance. And the house is much bigger than it looks in pictures. It turned out to be exactly what we wanted.I would definitely rent here again.
February 1, 2014 - Website
Catherine House Feb 2014
by Don S.
Experience was overall very good. some exceptions:Front BR toilet struggles to flush wellAnts were a problemFloors need deep cleaning; looked clean but were notOverall 4.5 of 5
January 1, 2014 - Website
Great Vacation Rental
by George P.
Catherine Cottage is a delightful place to stay in Key West. We have rented several cottages in Key West over the past twelve years and this was the best yet, Great location unless you want to be closer to the primary bar scene. It is well equipped although the "full size" refrigerator and dishwasher were on the small side. Also, the microwave oven is inconviently located. The bedrooms are quite large with king size comfortable beds, flat screen TVs and en suite bathrooms. The private pool is a particular delight.
December 1, 2013 - Website
Great vacation
by Reidun S.
Everything was in order very nice house .Location is great ,just around the corner from Duval Street .But jet very quiet .the rental was vey easy .We will be back .
November 1, 2013 - Website
As close to perfect as it can get.
by Recent Guest
We have rented from Rent Key West 3 years in a row now. You continue to privide excellent service. This time you had to service the pool and you did so immediately. JUST GREAT! Of all our stays, this property was the best place so far. It is obvious to see that the homeowners care about the place, and make a great effort to keep it beautiful. The renovations to the kitchen and back bathroom were a pleasant surprise! Thank you for a lovely stay and if we travel another couple again, we will return to this home.
October 1, 2013 - Website
Excellent in every way
by Recent Guest
From reservations to check out, this really was the perfect rental. The house is gorgeous and couldn't be better, really. Loved the location and new renovations!
Relaxing!
by Recent Guest
Wonderful experience......beautiful layout-cozy and inviting furnishings-private pool (which is why we chose this spot yet surrounding Palm trees made it difficult to tan). Location was great.....4 houses down from Duvall St....just a couple blocks from the Southern Most Point landmark, beaches & Butterfly Conservatory (which were all great)....and the neighborhood was quiet. (Be mindful that you are in Key West and there are other rental properties with tenants not so quiet). Make sure to stop by the local supermarket for any items you may need as parking is along the street and may not get a close spot. Check out Cole's Peace for fantastic fresh bread and breakfast sandwiches. And there is a 24hour market within 2 blocks. Could not ask for a better vacation.
Relaxing!
by Karlene H.
Wonderful experience......beautiful layout-cozy and inviting furnishings-private pool (which is why we chose this spot yet surrounding Palm trees made it difficult to tan). Location was great.....4 houses down from Duvall St....just a couple blocks from the Southern Most Point landmark, beaches & Butterfly Conservatory (which were all great)....and the neighborhood was quiet. (Be mindful that you are in Key West and there are other rental properties with tenants not so quiet). Make sure to stop by the local supermarket for any items you may need as parking is along the street and may not get a close spot. Check out Cole's Peace for fantastic fresh bread and breakfast sandwiches. And there is a 24hour market within 2 blocks. Could not ask for a better vacation.
August Weekend
by Nathan F.
This home was ideal for our vacation of 2 couples. The split floor plan of 2 Bedroom and 2 Bath with living room and kitchen in the middle make this home very comfortable. The home is very clean and location is great. 3 blocks from the beach and steps from Duval on the quieter side of Old Town. The dipping pool looked small in the pictures but was perfect for the 4 of us to relax in. We're looking forward to our next stay on Catherine Street!
Adventure in Paradise
by Paula P.
Catherine House was exactly as pictured on the website. Spotless and beautifully decorated. Highly recommend for a perfect stay in Key West.
Beautiful Cottage!
by Shirley R.
We loved the cottage. It was very clean, in a great location and quite comfortable. The dipping pool was refreshing to come home too.
Wonderful Escape
by Kerrie B.
Our stay in the Catherine House was wonderful. It was clean and comfortable. They thought of everything to make it just like home. The plunge pool was perfect. We will stay here again every time we visit.
Paradise Redux
by Maricely S.
I came to KW on a much needed escape and live like a native. Catherine House was definitely instrumental in getting me there. My stay there was truly a very pleasant experience and I wouldn't change a thing. Wasn't sure what to bring, but the house came with everything - including beach towels and sun block! Great location, beautifully decorated. The only cons were incredibly noisy neighbors and the bathroom adjacent to the bedroom in the back of the house had plumbing problems. Also a pool guy just walked into the property without announcing himself. Wish the rental agent had mentioned this prior, because it was startling. Other than that, I can't recommend the whole experience enough.
Great stay in key west
by Mary Beth M.
This house was a great place to stay. Plenty of room for two couples. Easy walk to everything. Great restaurants nearby, would definitely stay here again
Catherine House, A++
by Keith R.
We made an excellent choice in selecting the Catherine House. From the moment we walked through the front door, we knew this was a great choice. Very comfortable, clean, functional and certainly a most convenient location. Enjoyed staying on the south end of the island. We typically stay at guest houses and this was our first single house rental. We were very pleased. We will be back!
Catherine House
by Recent Guest
We loved the Catherine House!!! It was even nicer than we had expected. Just a half block away from Duval street. The house was clean, and perfect for 4 people to stay in comfortably. An added bonus, they sell fresh seafood across the street. I would stay here again!!
Catherine House
by Craig K.
We loved the Catherine House!!! It was even nicer than we had expected. Just a half block away from Duval street. The house was clean, and perfect for 4 people to stay in comfortably. An added bonus, they sell fresh seafood across the street. I would stay here again!!
In The middle of all
by Maxie W.
Very nice, walking distance from "Everything"! My only dislike was checking out at 10am! No, If's or But's about it. I know that check out is 11am standard with a courtesy of 1 hour more.
Great spot- great location!
by Cathi and Walt R.
The home looked just a depicted! Close to Duval, beach, and great restaurants and bars....could not be happier...
Nice love the location
by Recent Guest
Great overall experience love coming to key west and particularly the houses location. For us to be far enough away from the madness was a pleasure, but close enough to ride our bicycles anywhere we needed to. The house could use a little updating but overall a very nice house. Would definitely stay there again if we have only two couples.
Great Key West House just of Duval
by Scott P.
Great House on the quieter end of Duval, but still close enough to walk to everything. Beautiful historic design with all the modern amenities. Fully stocked kitchen with dishwasher and laundry makes it feel like home. The heated pool and private patio create wonderful indoor/outddor living. After arriving, didn't move the car once and walked to the beach, restaurants/bars and stores. Can't wait to go back.
February 1, 2013 - Website
Perfect getaway in Key West
by Recent Guest
loved key west,our second visit.Catherine house had everything we needed for the perfect holiday.very spacious,comfortable,homely.wonderful location,just off Duval street but the quieter end!we would definately come back and be happy to rent from the same company.
February 1, 2013 - Website
Perfect getaway in Key West
by Janette D.
loved key west,our second visit.Catherine house had everything we needed for the perfect holiday.very spacious,comfortable,homely.wonderful location,just off Duval street but the quieter end!we would definately come back and be happy to rent from the same company.
January 1, 2013 - Website
Winter 2013
by Recent Guest
A good rental property in a great location. Great neighbors.
January 1, 2013 - Website
Want to return
by Recent Guest
Liked the pool. Beds were great. We walked everywhere, liked the location. Neighbors were nice.
January 1, 2013 - Website
Catherine House
by Robert M.
A lovely property. Excellent condition, perfectly clean when we arrived,very private yard and nice, warm pool.
December 1, 2012 - Website
You won't do better than this property
by Doug L.
The location was perfect. It's a short walk anywhere you might want to be. The property itself is even better than you can envision from the pictures. Very spacious. Very clean. All the amenities you could need, washer & dryer, diswasher, grill etc. When we return to Key West we will not stay anywhere else.
December 1, 2012 - Website
A perfect hideaway
by Phil A.
We had never been to Key West before but we were looking to decompress after a very difficult and busy year. The Catherine House was perfect. Less than a block away from Duval street to take advantage of everything that it offers but private enough to simply enjoy the cozy back yard and heated pool. Lots of air conditioning and celing fans to keep the place cool.RentKW was great to deal with and it is located only a couple of blocks away. We will be back for sure
November 1, 2012 - Website
Most Relaxing Vacation Ever
by Pam M.
What a great house to relax in. We loved everything about it - the layout, decor, well-equipped kitchen, dipping pool, patio, and artwork. This is our 4th visit to the keys and one of the best times we've ever had in KW. We will return!