Where to Find the Best Key Lime Pie in Key West

No trip to the Florida Keys is complete without savoring a slice of our signature key lime pie. Indulge in Florida’s official state dessert in Key West, the birthplace of this delectable dessert. Check in to your Rent Key West Vacations home and discover the best key lime pie in Key West during your visit. This tangy treat is the perfect end to any meal, made with tart key limes that grow on the island, sweetened condensed milk, graham cracker crust, and meringue. From the family recipes of Key West Key Lime Pie Company to Kermit’s signature pie bars, every bakery on the island offers their own spin on this iconic dessert!

Kermit’s Key West Key Lime Shoppe

A Key West staple for over 30 years, Kermit’s Key West Lime Shoppe offers a wide range of key lime pies and products on Elizabeth and Duval streets. Order one of their traditional key lime pies made with tart key lime flavor, graham cracker crust, and topped with whipped cream. Or sample one of their pie bars dipped in dark, milk, or white chocolate.

Blue Heaven

Enjoy a slice of key lime pie amidst canopies of tropical foliage at Blue Heaven in the historic Bahama Village. Their key lime pie is made with a buttery cracker crust, freshly squeezed lime juice, sweetened condensed milk, and topped with meringue. They are one of the only restaurants in town that serve key lime pie with mountains of baked meringue!

Key West Key Lime Pie Company

The team at Key West Key Lime Pie Company has been making their pies the same way for 100 years. Stop in and try the family recipe, which uses all-natural ingredients, real key lime juice, and a handmade graham cracker crust. Then, go behind the scenes and learn how to make your own key lime pie during one of their classes. 

Key Lime Pie Bakery

Locally owned and operated, the Key Lime Pie Bakery offers freshly baked key lime pies daily. Pick up one of their signature pies and walk through the aisles, browsing key lime products like cakes, cookies, drink mixes, saltwater taffy, and tea. 

Moondog Cafe

Even visitors with dietary restrictions can enjoy key lime pie in Key West. Head to Moondog Cafe and try the mini gluten-free, vegan key lime pie, made with key lime coconut curd, toasted meringue, and a pâte sucrée shell. 

Reserve Key West Vacation Rentals and Condos

Head to our island to try the best key lime pie in Key West for yourself. Book your getaway with Rent Key West Vacations and let our knowledgeable, local staff help you plan your dream vacation. Enhance your stay with our concierge services and book a gift basket with key lime pie and sweets to welcome you as you walk in the door. Check out our vacation rentals and call us at 1-800-833-7368 to help narrow down the right property for your getaway!